Utah’s New Healthcare Directive Law: What’s Changed and Why It Matters
Episode Summary
Utah’s healthcare directive law was overhauled, and the new standardized form changes how Utahns appoint healthcare agents, name backup decision-makers, and document end-of-life preferences. Michael Haslam and Brian Edwards walk through the updated framework and explain what every existing directive needs reviewed against. The biggest structural change: the new form introduces “surrogates” — people who can step in to make healthcare decisions when no agent has been formally named or when the named agents aren’t available. That creates a backstop for anyone who put off naming a healthcare agent, but it also raises new questions about hierarchy and who gets called first in a crisis. The episode covers the practical mechanics: how the new form is organized, what each section now requires, when older directives are still valid, and what triggers a need to re-execute. Mike and Brian also address common confusion between a healthcare directive and a HIPAA authorization, the difference between living wills and POLST forms, and how to make sure your agent actually has the document when it’s needed — because a directive that’s locked in a file cabinet at home doesn’t help anyone in an ER. Anyone who signed a healthcare directive before 2026 should review it against the new framework; many older documents are still valid but no longer optimal.
Key Takeaways
Full Transcript
[0:00] Mike Haslam: Hi everyone. Welcome to our podcast. We’re excited to have you join us today. My name is Mike Haslam. I’m one of your hosts and I am joined by Brian Edwards. Hey Brian. Hello. What do you consider me now? Just a guest host every now and then or an expert every now and then that comes in? I don’t know. Yeah, I’m going to call you co-host Brian Edwards. I’ll take it. I like it. It sounds really official. I like it. I mean if you do something once or twice, you’re just a guest. But is this your third appearance or fourth? I think this is my fourth. Yeah. So I’m joined by my co-host Brian Edwards. That’s right. That’s right. It’s a new year. That means things change. That’s right. Yes. Happy 2026. Happy 2026. Looks like you’re doing well. You’re doing well.
[1:26] You’ve already started all your resolutions off perfectly. I’m doing good still actually. Yeah. I still have to remind myself what some of them are but on some of them that I remember, they’re good. I think if I actually asked you, do you feel comfortable sharing one with our audience Brian or are they pretty, you know? I’m happy to share one. I don’t mind one bit. I think it’s like what a lot of people have. I just get more fit, have more energy in life and that. And so I decided we’re just going to work out more. And I mean, yes, we’re in one of the weekends of the year but I did. I’ve done it twice now this week. That’s my goal right now is like just do what you can. Something more than I did before. It adds up. Something is more than nothing. I like it. It’s good. I’m workshopping mine still. So my 2026 goal is to have my 2026 goals by the end of January of 2026. There we go. We’ll report next time then I guess. Yeah. I don’t know where they are. Nothing has spoken to me yet. So I don’t like to make a goal just to make a goal. So I got to find something. That’s fair. That’s fair.
[2:51] What we’re going to talk about today, what changed was the Utah Health Care Directive Law or sometimes people will call it like a health care power of attorney or it’s also referred to sometime as the living will which is super confusing because the living will people think class will and testament not the same thing. The living will is usually the pull the plug scenario, right? So all those things are referred to living will, health care directive, health care power of attorney. They’re all codified in Utah under the same section and they’re really one in the same document now and we our legislature redid it all. They did. Yeah. There’s I mean there are some changes. I don’t think it’s overly drastic because what we had and we had something in place that worked well and I think it was good. There are some changes that we noticed as we went through that we just want to highlight today. But again I think there’s just some slight changes. The form change which is the big one and we’re going to talk about that. But yeah just reading through it. It’s I mean if I’m listening to this I’m like wait I already have one and you’re saying that this changes. I don’t think it’s yeah if you want to come in and talk about it we can talk about you know should we update it or not but I don’t I think what was in place is still a good system. This is just kind of tweaking it slightly to make it even a better system.
[4:20] Yeah they updated it or modernized it basically. Yeah. So just to be clear if you already have a health care directive or health care power of attorney it’s still valid right. Correct. If you haven’t looked at it in a while this is probably a good cue to revisit it. Would you agree? I’d agree. Sure. No time like now to do that. So there was two or three things they did completely different though that we haven’t really had in the code section which I think we both agree we like. And then what Utah and almost all states have done is they’ve came up with kind of like a standardized form for their health care directives. And the idea behind that is when you show up to a hospital and it’s urgent and you give the doctor or the medical provider this health care directive if they have to send it to legal and wait for three to four days for legal to review it and come back to the doctor and say hey this is what this power of attorney says this medical power attorney says like you know there’s could been hundreds of medical decisions that had to be made in those three to four days. So we’ve attempted to give our medical professionals a document that looks the same as much as so they can quickly determine what their patients wishes are and what the scope of their authority is. So we’re changing that.
[5:48] The form is going to change. Yeah. Yeah. And do we want to start with the form? Do you want to go there first? Yeah let’s start with the form. What did they change about the form? Well first off I mean this was the same with the other form and just straight out of the form is in the statute itself like it’s in the law the way that’s format and the questions are asked. It does say it’s an optional form so I mean if somebody really wants to go out there and create their own you’re still welcome to do so. But yeah if the state’s going to provide a form it’s best just to use what they have because then what you just said it’s standardized and whatnot. Going on to the form itself we have a copy here in front of us. Should we share our screen for those who are watching us on video? I can share mine. Yeah let’s do that.
[6:50] And as this goes on I mean the old form was five to six pages. This one same thing about five to six pages so it’s not really a lot of new information. There’s some new information. They reworry it just away and they ask the questions a little bit differently but yeah we’ll just go through it. One thing that doesn’t change right here on the beginning obviously is well we need your information and you get to list an agent. Who is going to act on your behalf if you cannot make these decisions? So that’s on the first page on the second page right there at the top is an alternate agent that hasn’t changed either. If you still want to list a second person or even more I’m sure you can still list as many as you want. This form only gives two but there’s no reason why you can’t list more. So the virility where we start getting into the changes is right where Mike’s at. This is part B. Now we’re going to list our healthcare instructions. Instructions just right here on the form. Oh sorry Brian yeah the format’s different because it jumps right to life sustaining treatment where before the old form had that at the end. Yeah. Right at the get go the question is the very first question is well let’s read the instructions first right. This section gives you the opportunity to say how you want your agent to act while making decisions for you. You may mark or initialize choice. You may also leave any choice blank.
[8:18] I think they add that just to make you know that you know this is all optional nothing on here is you must fill out this out form right. It’s all optional. So it makes it a little bit difficult for your agent to decide at that point I think but you can leave anything blank that you want to. Yeah with treatment first right like medical treatment. So when should they provide medical treatment versus just let you pass away right. So keep me alive is the term they use. Keep me alive but not needed for comfort. And what do you think of these five choices. Do you like how that’s broken it out a lot more. The old one just said I’ve told my agent just listen to them. It was very very very open ended. Yeah. This one makes it feel like you have to give a choice. Maybe there is an other where you can still write something like that and it’s like I’ve talked to my agent rather than let them decide. But here it’s just kind of giving you more of the choice. Always give it to me which was in the old one we had that option of keep me alive as long as possible. I think that’s what’s saying there. But then the next three options are not to be given to me if this condition occurs. The first one if the condition is curable and expected to cause my death soon then don’t give it to me. If you’re unconscious and not likely to retain your consciousness. Yeah.
[9:43] So yeah I mean we can read them all but I think just for to kind of make it easier for our listener like either you can list out the scenarios you would want them to not provide medical treatment you can initial those. Us as a firm we haven’t like beat this up yet and say hey do we like this language is this practical. But I mean the thing I would probably point out is the last one is other write what you want or don’t want. And I think this is where we will probably slip in like I’ve had a detailed conversation with my agent. You know just listen to my agent. That’s my initial thoughts. What do you think of that. Right. I think of that too. Yeah. That’s where we can put that in there. And it’s here under this first one again is about treatment. The second one is called food and liquids. The third one is pain relief. And that’s new right. The food and liquid we didn’t have anything in the old directives about that. Not at all. And that would get a little tricky because some people feel really bad like watching their loved one not eat or not drink and be like shouldn’t we be doing something there. And sometimes they didn’t talk about it. So I think I like that they put a section in if people want to. Again they don’t have to initial anything but they can. Yeah and once again it has other. So if we need to write something in there we can. And then the next section is pain and relief.
[11:12] It’s again saying yeah if you’re in significant pain do you want to remain comfortable even though it’s likely to shorten your life. Do you want to remain comfortable till the end of your life. And again so it has the same questions on situations where you can write. You can also write in other instructions. So all three of these questions they feel new at least they’re drafted differently. And it’s asked a different way on how you want to you know how you want to answer these questions. But that’s in here. And I kind of like how they just start off with that to be honest. Here’s the first thing that we’re going to do is talk about these. So yeah I really I mean I like how they left other in all these categories. I like how they broke it out more because a lot of our clients have that conversation with us and they’re like how does my agent know and we’re like well you need to talk to him. Or we can write something and put it in your plan for them to read later on but no one wants to take the effort to do that. And then so this is made it pretty easy. They can just check the ones they agree with and kind of have much more guidance for their agent. Yeah. OK then then the form switches to the priorities right.
[12:31] This seems to be about kind of helping the agent know what is most important to our to the person who filled out the form or our client if we are the ones helping them fill it out.
[12:50] Yeah. First two and all the answers are is this very important to me is it somewhat important to me or is it not important to me. Just saying you know it’s really just kind of your preference. What are your priorities? Yeah let’s pull two or three of these out as examples and just talk. Yeah kind of maybe say what like why that would be helpful if people knew that priority. Well the first to go hand in hand staying alive as long as possible. Do you want to stay alive as long as possible either for because of if you have a substantial physical limitation or mental limitation you know how important is that to you to stay alive or is it hold the plug as we say a lot of time like we’d rather just do that. So you get to say this is important to me or this is not so important to me. I think being independent is kind of interesting. Like how important is it to me to be independent. Why like I mean I don’t know if anyone marks it’s not very important. I don’t know if anyone’s going to say it’s not really important to me and I’m just trying to think if I’m a health care agent right and I know that the person I’m helping it’s really important for them to be independent. I guess I guess that could maybe change some of my decisions. Maybe we’re.
[14:19] Yeah. Yeah I can see that.
[14:25] Yeah but I mean I think the medical condition just dictates that no matter what right. Like yeah I know I want I know you want to be independent but you can’t you know you can’t do these five things by yourself anymore because your health. So yeah like I don’t that one to me feels weird but most of the other ones seem to make sense are there any others that seem to. I like one on here having my agent talk to my family before making decisions about my care. A lot of times I get a lot of clients who we list one child as the as the agent and then they tell me no no no but they can’t they need to talk to everybody first before anything is made clear or anything is decided. And so I always tell them well that’s possible they can talk to whoever they want to before they make a decision. But here it’s asking it saying is that important to you to make sure that all family members are are involved like do you want them to talk to all family members before a decision is made. For some people that may not be important I I can think of a handful of clients where they don’t want family members involved. But again I think it’s a place where they can mark hey make sure you talk to everybody before something is decided about my care. So I like that one.
[15:48] The next one is about friends too and which goes hand in hand but I think the family one is the is the kicker on that one. So anytime I read a contract especially like a document that’s going to give instructions to someone else to do I always like you know I always like well what if I get a call from a client that says hey the health care directive says my brother is supposed to tell me about what’s going on before they make any decisions for my mom and dad but they’re never but they’ve cut me out of the loop. We don’t talk you know we’re not on good speaking terms whatever it is they’re they’re cutting me out. Well then what right. Like did this did this really help and what can be done about that. And so that will be interesting to see how often we get that now because that was not in the last directive. Now the statute had some things about the agent had a duty to keep people reasonably informed and there was the previous statute kind of but now it’s in this form and I think we might be seeing those calls a little more often like they didn’t keep me in the loop. Yeah that’s good to know good to mention. This part C here optional special powers and guidance a lot of these questions came were in the old form as well. Can we be admitted to a facility. Can we get access to health care information.
[17:18] That was in the other form as well. So things just asking again. Well so what’s kind of different is this mental health treatment. That was not in the old form and the last statute didn’t address mental health very well. So my agent can do the following things only if I marked or initialed them below. Admit me to a voluntary patient sorry admit me as a voluntary patient to a facility for mental health treatment for up to 14 days whatever they write in. If I do not mark or initial this choice my agent may not admit me as a voluntary patient. That one is really interesting to me because we’ve done a lot of parents that have children that turn 18 that have significant mental health challenges. They’re like what do I you know like is there anything I can get in place to help take care of my kid when their mental health you know becomes to the point they need to be admitted or they need extra care like what can we have in place and before you know we try to we’d have to do kind of custom language to try to address that or get limited guardianships for them. We did we’ve done that a few times with guardianship that just limited to scope for health medical. And so I like that in there.
[18:49] Yeah that’s good. And then we have access to health information that’s pretty straightforward. And then this was one mean you talked about. Yeah. What’s your thoughts on that Brian. So it’s asking how flexible do you want your agents to be in caring for your wishes in this in this document. And basically the question or what you can answer is I get my agent permission to be flexible in applying these instructions if my agent thinks to be in the best my best interest based on what my agent knows about me. So technically if that’s marked an agent can probably go off of your instructions slightly or a lot if they think that that is in your best interest to do so. You don’t mark this the document says that they have to follow exactly what while the agent must follow the instructions even if your agent thinks something else is better for you.
[19:44] So it gives you the choice on how flexible you want your agent to be in caring for your instructions here. I think that’s I think it’s a good thing. It may go back to the to the part where we talked about you know I’ve talked to my agent in the last four more says we talked to the agent. They know my wishes. They know what I want. So it kind of alludes to that slightly. It’s it’s word obviously a lot different from that. But it’s still allowing them to have flexibility and being able to apply what you decide. And again you have the choice if you don’t select that then that just limits exactly what you have on the form here. I mean yeah. I think so people who check it we’re going to see a few family members misunderstand that as like I can do whatever I want. Yeah. And I think the key thing for everyone to remember is this best interest language right. Yeah.
[20:44] It’s fine if you deviate but you have to still have some justification why it was a surprise. Yeah. Yeah. So that’ll be interesting to see how that one impacts things. And then number four is you can nominate a guardian. That one’s pretty standard. You can donate organs that’s in there. You can clarify. Oh sorry this organ donation on that second page. Their purpose of the donation you can mark where you want your organs to go. What where where are we donating organs for to transplant therapy research education. That was not the last form is just hey do you want to donate your organs. So here it says well what what do you want to donate them for if you mark yes.
[21:23] I think that’s kind of cool that they’ve brought that out. I didn’t. To be honest I guess I mentally thought that there’s other reasons but I always thought like when you’re doing an organ it’s for transplant only. But here you go. Here’s some other reasons you can do it. Yeah.
[21:38] Yeah. Well and like I think this is a little broader so sometimes people actually donate you know the whole body to to education and research sometimes. So I think this allows like just a organ to. So that’s kind of cool. Yeah. One other thing that kind of jumped out to me and I was going to go double check it just didn’t ring a bell with me is you know it says hey this needs one witness needs to be an adult can’t be the person who’s going to be the agent. It can’t be the agent’s spouse or someone the agent lives with as a couple. So that last one I don’t remember if that I don’t remember that in the last version. So I was going to double check that. But basically if you’re not married but you have a significant other they can’t be a witness on it either.
[22:35] Yeah. I don’t remember either. But that’s a look at it. And then if you’re living or receiving care in a nursing home the witness cannot be an employee or contractor of the home or someone who owns or runs the home. So that’s kind of interesting too. So you can’t if you’re in the nursing home only nursing home. And so then I was going to look a little closer to the statute to see if that nursing home statutes can apply to assisted livings. So yeah.
[23:06] And that’s the new form. Yeah. So overall 1 to 10 what would you rate it Brian?
[23:15] Brian Edwards: I like it. I’d give it 8, 9 somewhere. I do like it. I think it’s good. It’s a missing couple parts probably. But overall I like how they rewarded it and brought out those specific questions a little bit more to help somebody really think through like what what are we talking about when we talk about life sustaining care and things like that. I do like it. I think it’s definitely an improvement. Definitely an improvement. So and then the law itself I mean the form addressed a lot of the changes. I think that why it made sense to kind of just walk through the form. But the law itself there’s one thing that was not showing up in the form that’s a pretty big change. This concept of a surrogate. How would you kind of describe that? Surrogate. Yeah. It’s it’s the surrogate is who will be the person that’s making health care decisions on your behalf if you don’t have the form in place is kind of where the statute leads to. So if you don’t have this form in place let’s look at statute and see who will be your surrogate who will be able to make these health care decisions on your behalf.
[24:29] So what do we mean by surrogate? So maybe maybe what’s the definition of a surrogate? Does the statute. Let’s maybe read it. It does list it. I did see it. Let me see.
[24:43] The way I think surrogate is just a person that’s authorized to make medical decisions for you. Yeah. And there’s an agent available. Yeah. An agent a default surrogate or guardian authorized to make health care decisions. Okay. That’s what the statute says. That’s close.
[25:01] This would probably be a situation where they just didn’t do a health care directive or is this more like they don’t have any family or. I think both.
[25:12] It goes through a list of again so if you don’t it says if you don’t have one but again like if you don’t have family or you just or whatever like it does have a list of people in order like well this is who will be next. Yeah. Priority list of who will be of who will be your agent. And I mean it’s it’s pretty I’m not gonna say common sense but logical in the order of like who will be like somebody that you name first if not then your spouse as long as you’re married to them. There’s a couple other nuances with that but I won’t get into that right now but a spouse adult child or adult parents a cohabitant an adult sibling and it just kind of goes down kind of extending from there. It stays within the family mostly but if you don’t have a family member then it will allow for people outside of your family so somebody who’s been assisting you for over six months in the preceding six months stepchildren if there are any of those.
[26:13] As cohabitant right and individuals cohabitant is in here. That’s an issue that’s even above an adult sibling. So before your siblings come in if you’re living with somebody that cohabitant can make decisions for you first. So yeah. Child or grandparent. So you just kind of it kind of starts who’s closest to you and then starts working its way out. Yeah. That’s I mean like it’s pretty reasonable is not the word I want to use. It makes sense I guess in the order that they listed in that regard is like yeah let’s keep it close and spread out from there. So this one’s interesting to me. So like you get through there’s no family and then it just says an adult who has assisted the individual with support decisions during the preceding six months. So routinely making routinely. Yeah that’s going to be interesting a little bit. The health care providers will have to decide if they’re going to accept those people as surrogates. I think that’s just going to fall on them to make their best judgments. So the doctor or the hospital. Yeah.
[27:23] Have you been helping them for six months. So yeah.
[27:28] But I mean even going down further you have stepchild next and then it’s any it looks like it’s an adult not listed any above who has exhibited special care and concern for the individual is familiar with their personal. Married. Yeah. Further I guess I could be I collapse on the sidewalk and some stranger finds me right taking to the hospital. I can see that being like a lot of like religious leaders. I see. That makes sense.
[27:59] And then last but not least doctors physicians. Yeah. And even they have certain requirements. They have extra rules right. Yeah. Because there’s some inherent conflict of interest for them as a medical provider. Yeah. And that’s listed out here on the statue. Yeah. That’s what we’ll say that for another day to go through all the works. You’re a doctor. Can you be a surrogate. I could be a whole episode. So I want to go back though Brian because the first category after spouse are the individual’s adult child. Right.
[28:38] So I got four kids two of them want me to get the surgery two of them want me not to get the surgery. I’m unconscious. I never did a health care directive. So they’re going to the surrogate statue.
[28:53] That’s where we land. And my kids are deadlocked.
[29:01] Is that a problem. Oh for sure. Yeah. And that’s I seeing that I mean I saw it’s the same level as an adult parent as well. I’m like well if my adult child and my adult parents they’re at the same level like what if one of them wants one of them wants it. So it’s the same thing. But so yeah. Yeah. If there’s a conflict there it’s I don’t know how they’re going to decide that or go from there.
[29:26] It’s court. Yeah. You have to go. Yeah. You’re going to go to court have a judge appoint guardian at that point. You’re just going to be petitioning to become the guardian. And while that’s happening while it’s going because that’s not going to happen overnight maybe it could I guess but probably won’t try to do emergency one and get it in a couple nights but it’s definitely not the same day thing or next day thing usually. Yeah. Sometimes it’s sometimes even the emergencies can go a week or two right. Right. Right. So so you can’t. So the surrogate thing I like it but the reason I point that out is people you can’t just have the soft false sense of I’m covered. My my kids can just make that decision or my parents or even my spouse. Oh my spouse will just decide it because what if you and your spouse are in the same car wreck and your spouse can’t give your medical decisions and then they go to your two kids and your two kids disagree and then they’re they’re going to be in court. Yeah. Situations that we can avoid a situation we want to avoid. Yeah. And the health care directors just so easy to do. It’s nice if you can do it with your attorney when you’re doing the rest of your estate planning because they can help you like tie it into the rest of your planning better and help you understand some of the choices you’re making in the document.
[30:45] But anyone can go to the you know Department of Health’s Web site print off this form we were showing fill it out get your neighbor to witness it. And that is that is just the bare minimum. Every adult over 18 should do that period. No questions asked. I should have. If you’re listening to podcasts and you have not done a health care directive you got to do it. And I’m just curious Mike just your opinion. I usually tell people on that agent to go two to three people deep.
[31:22] I don’t know what what’s your opinion on how many people should be listed as an agent or alternate agent. Yeah like two is like the bare minimum right. Three is ideal. Like I haven’t seen people go past three yet. I’m sure one day some weird and a lot of people think oh like oh that they’re not all going to die and that’s not what usually happens. It’s a voluntary job like people can quit. People can have health issues of their own so they aren’t they can’t they can’t be the agent like there’s a lot of things that cause your first choice not to be able to do the health care agent responsibilities. And yeah to like at least a primary and a backup but three is three is better. OK. But the form only allowed a space for two and so that’s why like the health care directive will be filling out their clients you know will be taking that form and adjusting it and adding things that we we will we’ll have an improved version that we use. So. Right. That’s right.
[32:29] Like it. Good. Well that’s that was good. I’m glad we got that out out of the way to start the year the new health care. If you didn’t do a new year resolution like me and you couldn’t come up with one now just do that. I gave you one do an updated health care director. You go. Yeah. It’s an easy win. You can feel good. You got to check out important done. Yeah that’s right. That’s good. So. OK. Great. Thanks everyone. We’ll catch you next time.
[33:02] You’ve been listening to legacy lawyers with Michael Haslam and Nathan Croxford. We give you the juicy detail of cases that our law firm has dealt with. We take out the lawyer talk and legalese and show you what options some of our clients had to choose from to fix their situation. The effects of not doing planning can be devastating. We’ll be back soon. But in the meantime look up with us on Facebook and Instagram at voyant legal. Call us at 8 0 1 9 5 1 0 500 or send us an email at team at voyant legal dot com and for commonly asked questions hit voyant legal dot com slash resources. We’ll see you next time.
Related Resources
Have a question of your own?
Schedule a Legacy Planning Session with Voyant Legal — flat fee, agreed in advance.
Schedule a Session